Looking for a taste of the local lifestyle? One of the best ways to understand a community is through its food scene, and Peoria, Arizona, is no exception. From modern gastropubs to wood-fired Italian favorites, the top restaurants in Peoria showcase the area’s growing culinary identity with character, comfort, and creativity.
Whether you’re house hunting or just exploring, here are six must-try restaurants that locals swear by.
1. Haymaker
Best For: Elevated comfort food and hearty brunches
Location: 24759 N Lake Pleasant Pkwy, Peoria, AZ
Haymaker is a Peoria staple known for its scratch-made American fare, generous portions, and warm neighborhood atmosphere. Originally a family-run burger joint, it has grown into a go-to spot for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Expect a menu packed with juicy burgers, BBQ plates, loaded fries, and comfort classics—alongside a standout brunch lineup featuring chicken and waffles, smoked brisket hash, and mimosas by the glass or flight.
Located just off Lake Pleasant Parkway, Haymaker is always buzzing with locals—especially on weekends. It’s the kind of place where families, couples, and solo diners alike can enjoy a satisfying meal in a casual but quality-driven setting.
Location: 24759 N Lake Pleasant Pkwy, Peoria, AZ
Haymaker is a Peoria staple known for its scratch-made American fare, generous portions, and warm neighborhood atmosphere. Originally a family-run burger joint, it has grown into a go-to spot for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Expect a menu packed with juicy burgers, BBQ plates, loaded fries, and comfort classics—alongside a standout brunch lineup featuring chicken and waffles, smoked brisket hash, and mimosas by the glass or flight.
Located just off Lake Pleasant Parkway, Haymaker is always buzzing with locals—especially on weekends. It’s the kind of place where families, couples, and solo diners alike can enjoy a satisfying meal in a casual but quality-driven setting.
2. Peoria Artisan Brewery & Gastropub
Best For: Craft beer lovers and gastropub enthusiasts
Location: 10144 W Lake Pleasant Pkwy #1130, Peoria, AZ
For those who appreciate craft beer and creative bar fare, Peoria Artisan Brewery & Gastropub delivers on both. This independently owned brewery has become one of the most respected restaurants in Peoria, AZ, thanks to its rotating taps, locally sourced ingredients, and inventive takes on classic dishes.
The menu goes well beyond typical pub food, offering items like elote fries, peach and bourbon brisket, and a number of creative burgers. Meanwhile, their small-batch beers—brewed on-site—span everything from crisp lagers to bold IPAs. Whether you’re grabbing a casual drink or sitting down for a full meal, this spot hits the mark for flavor and community.
Location: 10144 W Lake Pleasant Pkwy #1130, Peoria, AZ
For those who appreciate craft beer and creative bar fare, Peoria Artisan Brewery & Gastropub delivers on both. This independently owned brewery has become one of the most respected restaurants in Peoria, AZ, thanks to its rotating taps, locally sourced ingredients, and inventive takes on classic dishes.
The menu goes well beyond typical pub food, offering items like elote fries, peach and bourbon brisket, and a number of creative burgers. Meanwhile, their small-batch beers—brewed on-site—span everything from crisp lagers to bold IPAs. Whether you’re grabbing a casual drink or sitting down for a full meal, this spot hits the mark for flavor and community.
3. Bourbon & Bones Chophouse and Bar
Best For: Upscale dining and special occasions
Location: 24985 N 83rd Ave Suite 110, Peoria, AZ
Bourbon & Bones brings a high-end steakhouse experience to the heart of Peoria. This polished, modern chophouse is perfect for a celebratory night out, a business dinner, or just indulging in expertly prepared cuts of meat and fresh seafood.
Standouts include the 20-ounce bone-in ribeye, lobster mac and cheese, and the bourbon-glazed pork chop. The drink list is just as impressive, with a curated collection of rare bourbons, handcrafted cocktails, and boutique wines. For those seeking an elevated night on the town, this is one of the finest restaurants in Peoria, AZ.
Location: 24985 N 83rd Ave Suite 110, Peoria, AZ
Bourbon & Bones brings a high-end steakhouse experience to the heart of Peoria. This polished, modern chophouse is perfect for a celebratory night out, a business dinner, or just indulging in expertly prepared cuts of meat and fresh seafood.
Standouts include the 20-ounce bone-in ribeye, lobster mac and cheese, and the bourbon-glazed pork chop. The drink list is just as impressive, with a curated collection of rare bourbons, handcrafted cocktails, and boutique wines. For those seeking an elevated night on the town, this is one of the finest restaurants in Peoria, AZ.
4. The Sicilian Butcher
Best For: House-made Italian fare and modern vibes
Location: 9780 W Northern Ave Suite 1100, Peoria, AZ
Located in Peoria’s vibrant Park West District, The Sicilian Butcher brings a bold and modern twist to classic Italian cuisine. Known for its customizable meatball boards, hand-rolled pastas, and house-cured meats, this spot has quickly become one of the most talked-about restaurants in Peoria, AZ. Whether you're ordering a family-style spread or enjoying aperitivos on the patio, every detail is designed to celebrate Sicilian hospitality with a fresh, contemporary edge.
The space itself is as thoughtfully crafted as the menu, featuring an open kitchen, stylish butcher-block accents, and a lively bar scene. It’s an ideal choice for date nights, celebrations, or simply a great glass of wine with unforgettable food, all without leaving the neighborhood.
Location: 9780 W Northern Ave Suite 1100, Peoria, AZ
Located in Peoria’s vibrant Park West District, The Sicilian Butcher brings a bold and modern twist to classic Italian cuisine. Known for its customizable meatball boards, hand-rolled pastas, and house-cured meats, this spot has quickly become one of the most talked-about restaurants in Peoria, AZ. Whether you're ordering a family-style spread or enjoying aperitivos on the patio, every detail is designed to celebrate Sicilian hospitality with a fresh, contemporary edge.
The space itself is as thoughtfully crafted as the menu, featuring an open kitchen, stylish butcher-block accents, and a lively bar scene. It’s an ideal choice for date nights, celebrations, or simply a great glass of wine with unforgettable food, all without leaving the neighborhood.
5. Revolu Modern Taqueria + Bar
Best For: Bold flavors and vibrant atmosphere
Location: 15703 N 83rd Ave #110, Peoria, AZ
Situated in the P83 entertainment district, Revolu Modern Taqueria + Bar offers a fresh, playful take on classic Mexican street food. Think street tacos with elevated fillings like birria, crispy pork belly, and Baja shrimp—paired with creative margaritas and colorful plating.
The restaurant leans into its “modern cantina” vibe with upbeat music, eye-catching décor, and a full-service bar that’s a draw all on its own. It’s one of the most popular restaurants in Peoria for good reason: consistently delicious food, lively energy, and a menu that keeps regulars coming back for more.
Location: 15703 N 83rd Ave #110, Peoria, AZ
Situated in the P83 entertainment district, Revolu Modern Taqueria + Bar offers a fresh, playful take on classic Mexican street food. Think street tacos with elevated fillings like birria, crispy pork belly, and Baja shrimp—paired with creative margaritas and colorful plating.
The restaurant leans into its “modern cantina” vibe with upbeat music, eye-catching décor, and a full-service bar that’s a draw all on its own. It’s one of the most popular restaurants in Peoria for good reason: consistently delicious food, lively energy, and a menu that keeps regulars coming back for more.
6. Fabio On Fire
Best For: Authentic Neapolitan pizza and Italian hospitality
Location: 8275 W Lake Pleasant Pkwy #101, Peoria, AZ
Tucked into a strip plaza in north Peoria, Fabio On Fire surprises first-timers with its authenticity and heart. Chef-owner Fabio Ceschetti brings old-world techniques and passion to the table, crafting wood-fired pizzas, handmade pastas, and rustic Italian entrées that reflect his upbringing in Vicenza, Italy.
Signature dishes include the prosciutto e burrata pizza, cacio e pepe, and fresh-baked focaccia served with imported olive oil. With its intimate dining room, outdoor patio, and chef who often visits tables himself, Fabio On Fire offers a rare blend of authenticity and accessibility—an easy favorite among Peoria’s discerning diners.
Location: 8275 W Lake Pleasant Pkwy #101, Peoria, AZ
Tucked into a strip plaza in north Peoria, Fabio On Fire surprises first-timers with its authenticity and heart. Chef-owner Fabio Ceschetti brings old-world techniques and passion to the table, crafting wood-fired pizzas, handmade pastas, and rustic Italian entrées that reflect his upbringing in Vicenza, Italy.
Signature dishes include the prosciutto e burrata pizza, cacio e pepe, and fresh-baked focaccia served with imported olive oil. With its intimate dining room, outdoor patio, and chef who often visits tables himself, Fabio On Fire offers a rare blend of authenticity and accessibility—an easy favorite among Peoria’s discerning diners.
Why the Food Scene Matters When Moving to Peoria
When clients consider a move, they’re not just buying a home—they’re buying into a lifestyle. One reason buyers are increasingly drawn to the West Valley is the quality of everyday life, and Peoria’s growing number of exceptional restaurants is a testament to that.
These local favorites reflect the area's blend of small-town friendliness and big-city taste. With new concepts opening regularly and neighborhoods like Vistancia and North Peoria expanding rapidly, Peoria’s dining landscape is only getting better.
These local favorites reflect the area's blend of small-town friendliness and big-city taste. With new concepts opening regularly and neighborhoods like Vistancia and North Peoria expanding rapidly, Peoria’s dining landscape is only getting better.
Ready to Explore Peoria Living?
If you’re drawn to Peoria's lifestyle and dining scene, it may be time to consider calling it home. Whether you’re relocating from across the Valley or across the country, John Rowan offers expert guidance, local insight, and personalized service to help you find the right home. Reach out now to explore available properties and discover all the best Peoria has to offer.
